How to trade with indices – Explanation guide

Home » Here are the most popular trading assets around the world » How to trade with indices – Explanation guide

When we hear about markets being up, down, bullish, or bearish we are often actually talking about the performance of indices rather than the market itself. It is difficult to measure the stock market as a whole, so instead a lot of analysts use metrics that summarize the performance of a sample of stocks. These days indices are the basis of some of the most popular investment strategies.

Indices take a sample of stocks deemed to be representative of a country, sector, or other area and then somehow average their prices to come to the indices level. This level by itself does not matter much but by following its percentage changes over time, investors can approximate the movement of the underlying market. A lot of people use indices as a proxy for the markets they sample. In fact, it has become a popular practice to invest in the indices themselves to achieve market returns.

It should be noted that there are plenty of indices to choose from when trying to gauge the markets. In fact, there are more indices but only a few are as popular as the famous Dow Jones and S&P 500. In this article, we will further analyze what the indices mean and how it is traded in the financial markets. Besides, we will talk about what are the main differences between trading with indices and trading with Forex and indices vs forex which is more profitable.

Best indices Forex Brokers

Welcome Bonus
Min Deposit: N/A


What are indices and How Do They Work?

As we have already mentioned, one of the most widely watched indexes is the S&P 500 that is seen as of the best representations of US companies as it follows the performance of 500 at the largest but not the 500 largest US companies based on the market.

Another important index that should be noted here is the Nasdaq Composite Index which is unique in that it measures the price of stocks trading on its own market, also called the Nasdaq. The Dow, S&P 500, and Nasdaq all track the US stock market but indices exist for other countries as well.

If you are interested in following Canadian stocks you can check out the SP TSX composite. On the other hand, for a more global perspective, there is the MSCI World Index. These broad market indices track the performance of a large group of stocks in a country.

However, if you want to know more industry-specific information, there are indices that cover these issues as well. For example, if you wanted to follow US technology, Canadian banks, or international healthcare stocks, you could check the above-mentioned indices (including Dow Jones and S&P 500) in order to get an idea of how the markets have moved over time.

As you can see there are plenty of indices to look at when trying to compare the performance of your stocks to the overall market. On the other hand, their utility has a past as a mere point of reference. While talking about how index trading works it should also be stated that since indices like the SP 500 are meant to represent the market as a whole and because they are diversified by nature, a lot of investors have started using index funds as an easy way to gain investment exposure while keeping costs low.

The index fund is a mutual fund or more broadly an ETF that mimics an index by either holding all of its constituents or holding a representative sample. Because index funds simply copy an index they can operate at a lower cost and often charge you fees below half a percentage point. This makes them a popular option for passive investors who believe mimicking the market is better than trying to beat it. Though active investors have also adopted index funds as a way to expand and limit their exposure to certain industries and countries.

Most Traded Index in The World

Before explaining the indices compared to Forex it should be mentioned that there are several most traded indices around the world. Those indices include the S&P 500 index and The Dow Jones. When it comes to stock market indices, probably one of the heaviest traded around the world is S&P 500. The S&P 500 is based on, amongst other factors, the market capitalization of the 500 largest companies traded on the US market. The S&P is considered to be a truer reflection of the broader US stock market when you compare it to something like the Dow Jones.

It is traditionally a way of gaining broad exposure to large US-listed shares. So maybe rather than investing in one share, buying or selling the S&P gives you exposure to a whole cross-section of the US market. it has been really popular for decades and continues to be a very successful index even today. On the other hand, The Dow Jones Industrial Average is the second oldest US stock market index, after the Dow Jones transportation average. Even people who are not involved with trading into the financial markets are probably familiar with the Dow being used as a benchmark for a US stock market performance. It tracks the value of the 30 largest US stocks. This includes the companies such as Coca-Cola, Caterpillar, Apple, Microsoft, Nike, and McDonald’s. This information is being updated regularly to reflect the changing nature of US business.

If you are buying or selling the Dow Jones index, it is a great way of gaining broad exposure to a group of large US-listed shares. On the other hand, from the trading point of view, it is clearly a market that even on a quiet day can swing around quite substantially. Therefore this daily volatility is one of the main reasons that it appeals so much to most traders.

How are the Indices Traded?

While we talk about how index trading works there are several important things that traders need to take into account. First of all, traders should remember that different indices can provide totally different returns even if they track the exact same market segment. The reason for this is twofold.

The first is that indices may have different sample sizes and criteria, The Dow Jones for example has a much smaller universe of stocks than the S&P 500. The second reason which is a bit trickier to understand is that indices can follow different methods for calculating their level.

It should be noted that indices use one of four different weighting methods when averaging the prices of their stocks. depending on the method used, you may find an index moving at a different rate or even a different direction than other indices.

Let’s say we have four indices that all measure the price changes of the same three stocks. each index Falls one of four different weighting methods. So as the stocks change in value, each of the index levels will show a different return. The price way to index, for example, will give more weight to stocks with higher prices. This is the method used by the Dow Jones Industrial average. While it is simple to calculate, weights are sometimes arbitrary.

On the other hand, the market-cap-weighted index will instead give more weight to firms with larger cumulative share values under the belief that these companies are more representative of the underlying market. This is how the S&P 500 is calculated and it is a pretty intuitive method though it gives little representation to smaller companies.

The Equally Weighted Index is pretty self-explanatory. Each share regardless of size has an equal impact on the index level. Even though the indices all represent the same universe of stocks, we have represented totally different measures of their performance. None of which are necessarily superior or incorrect but each of which comes with its own strengths and weaknesses.

Indices Compared to Forex

While analyzing indices vs Forex which is better, we should keep in mind that trading with indices and with the currency pairs in the foreign exchange market are the two different things that are equally popular among millions of traders around the world. It is hard to say which is better to start with because it is reliant on the investors’ trading goals, interests, and financial capabilities of individual retail traders.

We can only list the main advantages and disadvantages in the hope that you will select the best one for yourself. On the other hand, it is essential to note that there are some critical elements that every trader must consider when deciding between trading with indices or Forex.

Those important factors include risk, research time, liquidity, and margin rates. We will further analyze each of them in the following paragraphs.

Risk Factor – Indices

We all know that trading in the financial world contains a lot of risks. Most people are interested in trading because their major motivation is to generate a substantial amount of money. However, not all of them manage to do that. The main reason for this is that there is always a high chance of losing money, no matter what financial market you choose or what type of securities you trade with. This logic is the same with both, Indices and Forex. Trading with them both is a very risky game.

However, while talking about indices vs Forex, it should be noted that trading in the foreign exchange market is way riskier than trading with the different indices. This is because of various reasons. To begin with, there are a lot more external factors that affect the Forex market rather than the indices, such as changes in monetary or fiscal policy, changes in interest rates, unemployment rate, various important indices (such as the Non-farm payroll index), and so on, they all should be taken into account before one decides to start trading in this market. All of these things cause an increase in volatility in the foreign exchange market.

Increased volatility indicates that the currency prices start to fluctuate rapidly at the given time. For example, when the news is being published, or some important meeting is being held by an essential financial institution, it affects the overall market performance so much that the currency prices change very quickly, so almost anything can change at any minute. This means that at this sensitive time, no one really knows what direction the market performance will have in the near future. So when the FX traders open their positions at this time, they usually lose a big amount of money and experience a big downside in this financial market. Another reason why trading in Forex is way riskier than trading with indices is the leverage which we will analyze in the next section.

Research Time/Needed Knowledge – Forex

While analyzing trading indices VS Forex, it is important to note that the time that each of them needs to be analyzed thoroughly is different. In terms of time efficiency, it should be stated that indices are way better than Forex. This is because each index needs way less time to be understood and analyzed compared to the foreign exchange market. There is nothing hard and complex about learning about indices; this is because they are usually influenced by a single source rather than multiple of them.

On the other hand, the research time needed to analyze the foreign exchange market is huge which is why this market is considered to be less time-efficient compared to trading with the indices. The main reason for this is that there are several critical terms in the Foreign exchange market that every trader is recommended to understand before beginning trading. Leverage, spread, pips, trading accounts, lot sizes, and so on are all examples. This is why most skilled traders recommend the newcomers to conduct extensive research on all of these trading features, learn everything there is to know about these crucial concepts and study how they actually work in this financial market before opening trading positions in FX.

All these facts indicate that the new trader who just takes their first steps into the foreign exchange market is required to understand way more complex things compared to other traders, which means that it will take more time for them to become familiar with all the important features of FX and to reach success in this financial market in general.

Liquidity – Forex

The degree to which an item may be rapidly bought or sold in the market at a price that reflects its true worth is referred to as liquidity. Cash is widely regarded as the most liquid asset since it can be exchanged into other assets in the fastest and the most efficient way.

Liquidity is a very important concept when it comes to trading with different types of securities. The higher the liquidity level the better and more beneficial it is for every investor as it gives them a chance to buy or sell their securities more easily and quickly at the same time.

When we talk about indices vs Forex which is more profitable, it should be noted that Forex is a winner at this point. This is for various reasons.

First of all, it should be stated that the fact that the foreign exchange market has a significantly higher liquidity position than the indices is one of the reasons why so many investors prefer to trade in it. This is primarily true since FX trading is done on currencies, which are already the result of liquidity in certain ways. indices, on the other hand, are just assets that must be turned into cash before being assigned a liquidity factor. As a consequence, when comparing stocks with trading with the foreign exchange market, we can simply state that the FX is the obvious winner in terms of liquidity factor.

Margin Rates – Forex

Margin Rates in the financial markets are typically linked to the Leverage Principle. Leverage is a debt that a trader obtains from a specialized broker firm in order to earn a large profit with a little initial capital to be deposited. The indices, as we all know, are not as leveraged as the foreign currency market. To be more explicit, the highest leverage in FX is likely to be 1:2000 or beyond. On the other hand, while trading with the indices, there is very low or almost no leverage at all. This means that In terms of the leverage ratio, it is simple to observe how much of a difference there is between these two securities.

Another noticeable thing that should also be mentioned while explaining indices vs Forex is that the main advantage of using a high leverage ratio in the foreign exchange market is that it allows most investors to spend their capital much more efficiently and create the maximum return that they would not otherwise be able to produce.

However, every Foreign exchange trader should be aware that employing this trading instrument necessitates a substantial amount of market knowledge as well as expertise. If you do not completely grasp how this instrument works in this financial market, it is not suggested that you use it in your trading if you want to prevent any unpleasant circumstances or mistakes that may come up in FX in the future. Overall, it can be said that the Forex market is an obvious winner when it comes to high Margin rates and Leverage ratios.

Final Words on stocks vs Forex which better

In this article, we have already analyzed that Indices serve as a basis for many popular investing strategies. When attempting to measure the markets, there are several indices to pick from. There are other indices, but only a handful are as well-known as the Dow Jones and S&P 500.

The S&P 500 is based on the market capitalization of the 500 largest corporations trading on the US market. This index is seen to be the most accurate representation of the larger US stock market. The Dow Jones Industrial Average, on the other hand, is the second oldest US stock market index, behind the Dow Jones Transportation Average. The Dow is being used as a benchmark for US stock market performance. It tracks the value of the 30 largest US stocks. Trading indices and currency pairings in the foreign exchange market are two distinct activities that are equally popular among millions of traders worldwide.

However, there are major differences between these two. The major distinctive factors are risk, research time, liquidity, and margin rates. For example, investing in the foreign exchange market is far riskier than trading with the different indices. This is majorly due to the fact that rather than indices, there are a multitude of external variables that influence the Forex market.

Top 5 Forex Brokers

✔️ Spreads from 0.4 on FX pairs
✔️ TradeLocker trading platform
✔️ Instant withdrawals
✔️ Regulated broker

✔️ Tight spreads
✔️ No commissions
✔️ Up to 30:1 leverage
✔️ Instant execution

Not Verified

✔️ Negative balance protection
✔️ Ultra-fast execution
✔️ Professional Customer Support
✔️ Mobile trading apps

✔️ More than 300+ CFDs
✔️ MetaTrader 4 platform
✔️ Educational resources
✔️ Convenient payment method

Top New Prop Firm

✔️ EAs allowed
✔️ Daily payouts
✔️ Up to 90% split
✔️ News & Weekend Holding

New Trading Platform

✔️ 500+ Assets
✔️ One platform, multiple devices
✔️ One-click trade​
✔️ 0.01 spread